The federal government considered relocating viequenses to St. Croix

Puerto Rico Daily Sun

During the first years of World War II, the U.S. Navy expropriated most of the island of Vieques for military use. By 1944, the Navy decided that it would have no need for some of the expropriated land, and considered a request by the government of Puerto Rico to release some of it for agricultural use. However, the Navy kept the title to any and all of the land partitioned for this use.

The newly created Puerto Rico Agricultural Company, or PRACO, was given jurisdiction for the lands the Navy ceded to the local government. PRACO was committed to preparing an elaborate plan for the resettlement of former Vieques residents, and for experimenting with pineapple growing and cattle raising. At that time, 1947, Vieques had 15,000 residents.

Even as this land was being leased to the Puerto Rican government, there were rumors that the Navy planned to take it back and acquire the rest of the privately owned lands so that the whole island would belong to the Navy. According to Admiral Daniel E. Barbey, Commander of the Tenth Naval District, who lived in the now demolished house in what is today Paseo Caribe, the Navy had canvassed the South and Central American coasts, and the Atlantic seaboard, and found that only the Vieques met the Navy’s requirements to simulate land maneuvers. Admiral Barbey stated that Vieques was critical for the “interest of national defense.” He understood, however, that to carry out this plan, he must have Congress’ approval and a substantial appropriation. He was prepared to request both.

In order to make up for the loss of agricultural land, the Department of the Interior proposed that the present population of Vieques be transported and resettled in St. Croix. Then-Department of the Interior Acting Director Irving Silverman said St. Croix is “entirely agricultural and sparsely populated,” the island could support not only the 15,000 people living in Vieques, but substantially more from mainland Puerto Rico. Note that at no time were the viequenses consulted on this proposal.

In a 1947 memo, Silverman stated that St. Croix would benefit from growing pineapple, grazing cattle, and growing sorghum. These activities would provide more employment than the sugar cane industry currently provided under the auspices of The Virgin Islands Company. In any case, the operations of The Virgin Islands Company had never been profitable and depended on federal subsidies and the rebate of the rum tax from sales in the U.S. However, at this time, rum sales had fallen (in Puerto Rico as well), so the sugar operation, according to Silverman, was no longer justified.

The federal government’s proposal required that the relocation and resettlement of the 15,000 viequenses to St. Croix be done with funds from the Puerto Rican government, specifically through PRACO and the Puerto Rico Industrial Development Company. The Navy would have to put up some money in order to acquire additional lands in private ownership. Also, the Navy might be asked to transport the Vieques residents to St. Croix, and provide some small vessel to be used as a ferry between Puerto Rico and St. Croix.

Gov. Jesús T. Piñero received this proposal with great enthusiasm, pointing out that there was more land on St. Croix than on Vieques, that the pineapple operation would furnish more employment than the sugar industry, and that there was already a sizeable number of Puerto Ricans living on St. Croix. The plan would also serve to overcome some of the overcrowded conditions in Puerto Rico. Gov. Piñero added that there did not appear to be any other practical alternative, as something must be done about the people who will be taken off Vieques by the Navy, and “it is certain that they cannot be accommodated on the main island in anything approaching a satisfactory manner.” In any case, Gov. Piñero was in no position to take on the U.S. Navy.

U.S. Virgin Island Gov. William H. Hastie, the first African-American to hold this position, was not consulted on this matter, as Gov. Piñero, the Navy and Silverman imagined that there would be some reluctance on the part of the Virgin Islanders and specially of the St. Crucians to this widespread influx of Puerto Ricans. Fortunately for all those involved, this plan was never implemented.