The state of local manufacturing then and now

Puerto Rico Daily Sun

Manufacturing has been the centerpiece of Puerto Rico’s economic development for the past 60 years. Currently, Puerto Rico has lost its competitive edge, and is rapidly having to look for a replacement. The challenges faced at the beginning of the industrial period –lack of risk capital, lack of administrators and engineers, lack of infrastructure (water, power and roads) and limited knowledge of the U.S. marketplace- are quite different from those faced today. Puerto Rico is still confronted with a lack of risk capital for start-up ventures. However, the Island suffers from a risk averse culture, as few entrepreneurs willing to take risks. Also, Puerto Rico has a limited technological infrastructure, global competition offers lower cost business opportunities elsewhere, our public educational system is substandard, and the 936 Federal Tax benefits are forever gone. A look at how some of these challenges were overcome during the initial industrialization period might offer some clues as to opportunities available at the present time. We will concentrate this write up on the struggle regarding risk capital between the Puerto Rico Manufacturer’s Association (PRMA) and the Development Bank.

There were few locally owned manufacturing factories in Puerto Rico between 1942 and 1948. A profile of the 2,300 members of the Puerto Rico Manufacturer’s Association (PRMA) reveals that 27 percent were in the cigar industry, 13 percent in the retail food industry, and the remaining 60 percent were in other miscellaneous small businesses. These firms were in need of capital, and were under the impression that they would receive a more favorable treatment from the Development Bank than from the private banking sector. However, this was not to be.

According to Vicente León, Secretary General of the PRMA, the Development Bank did not approve loans to business that did not own their real estate. León stated that if the Bank was really interested in helping small businesses, they would also accept machinery and equipment as collateral. Ironically, according to León, these were the same requirements needed to qualify for a loan from private commercial institutions. PRMA argued that the Bank should modify its loan requirements in order to benefit small industries, and not cater exclusively to large industries that owned their facility, had a solid financial situation, and were able to negotiate loans with any commercial financial institution.

Rafael Buscaglia, president of the Development Bank, answered the PRMA’s onslaught by declaring that the Development Bank could not and would not approve loans when it thought it could not recuperate its investments. Doing so would seal the Bank’s future. The Bank should not, under any circumstances, approve loans, private or public, which it thought would fail. In an interview with El Mundo, Buscaglia explained that “the Bank is not an institution of subsidies, but a commercial institution that wishes to promote Puerto Rico’s economic development through sound and prudent banking practices”.

The Bank acted on Buscaglia’s advice, vision, and leadership. He did not place the Bank in financial risk by promoting the approval of speculative loans. In fact, the Bank’s loans were highly collateralized and of limited risk. An analysis of the Bank’s financial statements confirms this, as it revealed that most of the Bank’s income resulted from passive investments, while only a small portion of profits was attributed to interest from the loan portfolio. Between 1944 and 1947, passive investments increased from $9,300,000 to $49,700,000, while loans increased from $900,000 to $6,600,000.

The Development Bank pursued a course so as to not compete with the private banking industry. As a percentage of its assets, it loaned less capital than Banco Popular, Banco de Ponce, and Banco Crédito, the three largest locally owned banks operating in Puerto Rico. According to the financial statements made available during our study, from 1944 to 1948 –the years in which the Development Bank operated- it approved loans valued at 16.9 percent of its assets, Banco Popular approved 22.0 percent, while Banco de Ponce approved 34.0 percent. What does this information tell us about the Development Bank’s commitment to issue and approve loans? Simply put, this institution left the development responsibilities in the hands of the private banking institutions; while it concentrated its efforts in areas where, at the time, private banking had little or no expertise, like issuing bonds.

Today, we can also ask ourselves the same question: should the Government Development Bank (or for that matter, the Economic Development Bank) be in the business of investing in high risk ventures with local entrepreneurs? Given the fact the manufacturing base of the Island is being eroded by factors that are difficult for Puerto Rico to control, it is time to retake the arguments of long ago and give them another look. They just might hold the key to our future.